10 Key Considerations When Switching Email Security Providers
Sept 24, 2025 - Thad Legg
Email remains the #1 threat vector for cyberattacks and choosing the right email security provider is more critical than ever. Whether you're upgrading from a legacy solution or consolidating tools, switching providers can be a game-changer for your organization’s security posture. At Virtual Graffiti, we partner with industry leaders like Proofpoint, Barracuda, Abnormal Security, Fortinet FortiMail, OPSWAT, OpenText, Microsoft, and Trend Micro to help clients make informed, strategic decisions.
10 Essential Things to Consider When Switching Email Security Providers
-
Multiscanning Capabilities
Why settle for one antivirus engine when you can have many? OPSWAT’s Multiscanning technology leverages 20+ AV engines to detect threats faster and more accurately. If layered defense is your priority, this is a must-have. -
MSSP Support for Migration
Migrating email security can be complex. Bringing in a Managed Security Service Provider (MSSP) like those certified by Proofpoint (Cough Virtual Graffiti Cough) ensures a smooth transition, minimizes downtime, and helps with policy tuning and user training. -
Email Archiving Needs
Do you need archiving built into your email security solution? Some platforms like Barracuda, Proofpoint, and OpenText offer integrated archiving, which simplifies compliance and eDiscovery. Others may require separate tools, so plan accordingly. -
MX Record vs. API-Based Security
Traditional solutions reroute email via MX records, while newer platforms like Abnormal Security use API-based integration with Microsoft 365 or Google Workspace. API-based models offer faster deployment and deeper behavioral insights but may not suit every environment. -
Gartner Magic Quadrant Recommendations
Check the Gartner Magic Quadrant for Email Security. Providers in the top-right corner (leaders) offer strong vision and execution. Microsoft, Proofpoint, and Trend Micro consistently rank high, but always match their strengths to your needs. -
User Count & Scalability
Some solutions are better suited for SMBs, while others scale effortlessly to enterprise-level deployments. Knowing your user count can help eliminate options that don’t fit your size or growth plans. -
Threat Intelligence Integration
Does the provider offer real-time threat intelligence? Platforms like Fortinet FortiMail and Trend Micro integrate with global threat feeds to proactively block emerging threats. -
Ease of Management & Reporting
Look for intuitive dashboards, automated reporting, and granular policy controls. Barracuda and Microsoft Defender for Office 365 shine in this area, making life easier for IT admins. -
Compatibility with Existing Infrastructure
Ensure the solution integrates seamlessly with your email platform, SIEM, and endpoint protection. Compatibility issues can lead to gaps in coverage or operational headaches. -
Support & SLA Guarantees
Don’t overlook support quality and service-level agreements. A responsive support team and guaranteed uptime can make all the difference during a crisis.
Final Thoughts
Switching email security providers isn’t just a technical decision, it’s a strategic one. At Virtual Graffiti, we help clients navigate this journey with expert guidance and partnerships with the best in the business.
Need help choosing the right solution? Reach out to our team and we’ll help you find the perfect fit based on your environment, goals, and budget.